wombat_socho (wombat_socho) wrote,
wombat_socho
wombat_socho

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Murtha and Petain

Captain Ed refers to Marshal Petain in his dismissal of Congressman Murtha (D-PA) and his call for withdrawal from Iraq. Murtha's overwrought "chickenhawk" accusations against Vice-President Cheney aside, I agree that Ed's got a point there. Petain's surrender in 1940 was caused mainly by his concern for the French Army, which could have continued fighting at the cost of more casualties, a cost which Petain, well known for his concern for the troops, was not willing to pay.

Now, it's not really fair to compare Petain's horrific experiences in World War I as commander at Verdun to Murtha's tour of duty in Vietnam; it's a tremendous disservice to the old Marshal. However, one can see the similarity. Ed and others are also right, though, to point out that Murtha has never been a hawk on the war. As Bryan Preston points out over at Michelle Malkin's place, he was against the war before he was against it.
Tags: culture & politics
Subscribe
  • 2 comments
  • 2 comments

Comments for this post were locked by the author